Explore faith, single-motherhood, cultural diversity, and political musings along with me as I share random thoughts from my life's journey. I would love to hear about your road less travelled.
Friday, December 22, 2006
Mormon Women...read the full article at www.fairlds.org
Mormon women, like other religious women, find incongruence at times in what Riffat Hassan has called the "gap between theory and practice…" suggesting at times a difficulty that women face in finding gender equality in their religions, especially when scriptures, doctrines, and cultural practices might suggest a hierarchy of gender within that religious tradition.13 However, Mormon women still seek ways of negotiating their gendered experiences within their established institution; of course, they deny any outside pressure to reject their religion outright, because "[i]f the feminist message is posited in a strict polarity between feminism and traditional religion, making women think they have to choose between the two, then many of the world's women will choose their religion." Here, Preston invites a useful comparison to the women of Islam. Quoting from Muslim feminist Azizah al-Hibri, "The majority of Muslim women who are attached to their religion will not be liberated through the use of a secular approach imposed from the outside." Feminist Farida Shaheed also advised against making Muslim women reject the foundation of their faith: "[A] women's movement needs to be perceived as rooted in the cultural reality of the society in which it operates… [D]iscriminatory laws sanctified through Islam cannot be effectively countered with arguments which deny or discard Islam."14 Thus, rejection of a woman's religious framework will only create alienation and divisiveness. "A woman who is a practicing member of a religious institution is inevitably going to be hesitant to accept advice from someone 'who does not understand her value system and her commitment to it.'"15
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
Your line from above pretty neatly sums up what FAIR seems to be all about:
"People will be extremely creative in finding ways to maintain the 'status quo'."
Feminist Farida Shaheed also advised against making Muslim women reject the foundation of their faith ...
I guess that puts the kibosh on any Mormon plans to proselytize to Muslim countries ...
[A] women's movement needs to be perceived as rooted in the cultural reality of the society in which it operates…
Sounds reasonable enough, but is anyone arguing that there's some women's movement in the US that was/is not rooted in US cultural reality? That has been concerned with inequities in US culture for some reason other than that its ranks were composed of US women who supposed that their society was capable of coming up with a better offer than the deal that was put on the table?
Oh, but then I guess what's actually being argued here is not this, but that Mormon identity is so strong as to constitute a separate cultural reality and a distinct society such that Mormom women are so very different from the rest of the country's women that their problems are better left to the Mormon patriarchy to resolve lest our women's religious sensibilities become offended by culturally insensitive secular feminists ...
... Preston invites a useful comparison to the women of Islam.
Such a comparison seems completely disingenuous to me. It's useful only to an author pitching to a Mormon audience the notion that they should expect outsiders to show at least as much deference to their Mormonism as should apparently be shown to a Muslim woman's culture.
I mean 'apparently' in the sense that
1) I suspect the advice would change if an actual Muslim woman's husband decided to join the Mormon church ...
2) It depends on the audience holding the same fuzzy notion of a monolithic Islam that is prevalent in the US ... 'Islam' is no less broad a category than 'Christian', with its Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Baptist, Coptic, Mormon, etc., etc. flavors ...
3) God Bless America, baby ... Mormon women live in one of the most tolerant societies on the planet ... to equate a North American Mormon woman's experiece to that of a generic Muslim woman is to invite the reader to consider whether such a comparison does not trivialize the real persecution that many Muslim women face in countries that are run by fiercely secular US-backed authoritarian regimes that suppress and outlaw Muslim practices and beliefs. There are certainly women's movements based inside Muslim countries that operate very much within the local cultural tradition and very much against their oppressive governments, and I'm afraid they might find the comparison between their struggle and that of Mormon women in North America to be a feeble attempt at dressing up a 150-year old persecution complex that, no matter how free and tolerant the US may become, Mormons just can't seem to let go ...
Post a Comment